Mackinac Island Itinerary: The Perfect 2-Day Escape to Michigan’s Most Charming Island
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. This website contains affiliate links, meaning that I may earn a commission if you make a purchase through those links. For more information about my affiliate partnerships, please visit my terms and conditions.
I’d dreamed of visiting Mackinac Island ever since I first heard about the magical, car-free island where horse-drawn carriages still rule the roads and fudge shops outnumber stoplights. This summer, that dream finally came true—and it was every bit as enchanting as I imagined. In this post, I’m sharing my tried-and-true Mackinac Island itinerary—a two-day adventure full of historic forts, scenic bike rides, and, yes, plenty of Mackinac Island fudge.
Whether you’re planning a weekend getaway or road tripping through northern Michigan, this itinerary will help you make the most of your visit with personal tips, firsthand insight, and a few hidden gems you won’t want to miss.
Getting to Mackinac Island
Getting to Mackinac Island is all part of the adventure. Since there are no cars allowed on the island, the only way to arrive is by ferry or, if you’re feeling extra fancy, by small plane.
For most travelers (myself included), the Mackinac Island ferry is the way to go. You can catch a boat from either St. Ignace or Mackinaw City—we chose to depart from St. Ignace and bought a two-day pass from Star Line Ferry, which made it easy to come and go as we pleased. Shepler’s Ferry is another solid option, and both offer luggage transfer services if you’re staying overnight on the island.
Where to Park
If you’re staying on the mainland like we did (more on that in the next section), you’ll find both paid and free long-term parking options near the ferry docks. I recommend arriving early to secure a good spot, especially in summer.
Best Time to Visit Mackinac Island
The island is open year-round, but the season really kicks off in May and runs through October. For a festive twist, try to plan your Mackinac Island itinerary during the Lilac Festival in June—it’s a celebration of spring blooms, local food, and all things purple. We visited in mid-summer and loved the warm days and cool breezy evenings.
Pro tip: Morning ferries tend to be less crowded, and the light is perfect for photos as you approach the island.
Where to Stay for Your Mackinac Island Itinerary
When planning your Mackinac Island itinerary, one of the first big decisions you’ll make is whether to stay on the island or off it. Both options have their perks—and I’ve personally done the budget-friendly route by camping just across the water in St. Ignace, which worked perfectly for our two-day visit.
Staying on the Mainland (Budget-Friendly Option)
If you’re traveling on a budget or road tripping through Michigan, staying in St. Ignace or Mackinaw City is a great option. You’ll save a good chunk of change and still be just a quick ferry ride away from the island fun. We set up camp at a lakeside campground in St. Ignace and loved waking up to views of Lake Huron before catching the morning ferry.
Recommended St. Ignace Stays:
- Cedars Motel – Clean, cozy, and super affordable
- Sunset Motel at Armand’s Garden – Cute landscaping and lake views
- Breakers Resort – Lakeside – Budget-friendly with ferry packages available
Staying on Mackinac Island (For the Experience)
If you’re looking to lean into the island magic, staying overnight on Mackinac Island itself is unforgettable. From charming B&Bs to iconic resorts, you’ll have the whole place to yourself after the day-trippers leave.
Top Picks:
- The Grand Hotel – Over-the-top luxury, history, and the world’s longest porch (worth a visit even if you don’t stay here!)
- Mission Point Resort – A classic choice with lake views, spa services, and family-friendly vibes
- Bicycle Street Inn & Suites – Centrally located, great for easy access to shops and restaurants
No matter where you stay, book early—especially if you’re visiting during peak season or the Island Lilac Festival.
Day 1 of Your Mackinac Island Itinerary: Biking, Arch Rock & Island Charm
We arrived on Mackinac Island in the early afternoon—just in time to dip our toes into the magic without rushing. Whether you’re coming from a nearby campground in St. Ignace (like we did) or staying on the island, this first day is perfect for getting oriented, soaking in the views, and starting your adventure on a relaxed note.
Rent Bikes & Start Exploring
Once you step off the ferry, the vibe shifts immediately. There are no cars here—just bikes, horses, and a slower pace of life. Head straight to one of the many bike rental shops near the docks (like Mackinac Island Bike Shop or Ryba’s Bike Rentals). You can rent by the hour or for the full day—just be sure to bring a credit card and photo ID.
We opted for a 2-hour rental to do a mini loop of the island. If you have more time, I highly recommend the full 8.2-mile M-185 coastal loop, the only state highway in the U.S. where motor vehicles are banned. It’s flat, paved, and ridiculously scenic.
Stop at Arch Rock
Whether you’re doing the full loop or just a portion, make time for Arch Rock—one of the island’s most famous landmarks. Park your bike at the bottom and climb the stairs for a sweeping view of Lake Huron’s turquoise water framed by the natural limestone arch.
Insider Tip: The stairs are steep, but the view is totally worth it. Bring water and wear shoes you don’t mind walking in.
Take the Scenic Way Back
On your way back toward town, consider a detour through the quieter interior roads or Marquette Park, which sits just below Fort Mackinac and offers a lovely spot to relax in the grass with views of the harbor.
Once you return your bike, spend time browsing the shops along Main Street, grabbing a drink, or stopping for an early dinner if you’re staying on the mainland and need to catch the last ferry back.
If you’re staying overnight on the island: Stick around to enjoy Mackinac in its peaceful after-hours glow. Once the day-trippers leave, the island becomes even more magical.
Day 2 of Your Mackinac Island Itinerary: History, Horse-Drawn Carriages & Grand Views
With a full day ahead and so much still to see, we caught one of the first ferries over to Mackinac Island and hit the ground running. If your goal is to soak in the best of the island’s history, nature, and iconic architecture—all in one day—this is the way to do it.
Step Back in Time at Fort Mackinac
Start your morning at Fort Mackinac, perched high above the harbor on a limestone bluff. It’s one of the most popular things to do on Mackinac Island—and for good reason. The views alone are breathtaking, but the real magic is in the history.
Built by the British in the late 1700s and later transferred to American hands, the fort has seen more than a few power shifts. You can explore 14 original buildings, watch live demonstrations, and even peek inside the quirkiest restrooms you’ll ever find—in converted soldier quarters, complete with clawfoot tubs.
Tip: Arrive early to beat the crowds and enjoy cooler morning temps
Picnic Lunch with a View
After your history fix, it’s time to refuel. Stop by Doud’s Market—the oldest family-run grocery store in America—for picnic supplies. Grab a fresh sandwich, some fruit, and a few local snacks, then head back to Marquette Park or down to the harbor for a scenic picnic.
Want something sweet afterward? You can’t leave the island without indulging in a scoop of ice cream. Try Sadie’s Ice Cream Parlor at the Grand Hotel or one of the many downtown shops offering flavors like Mackinac Island Fudge (yes, it’s a flavor and yes, it’s delicious).
Ride in a Horse-Drawn Carriage
If your legs are tired from all the walking and biking, this is the perfect time for a carriage tour. These horse-drawn rides are a Mackinac Island must-do. You’ll get a narrated overview of the island’s history and natural beauty—all while relaxing in a comfy open-air carriage.
Tours typically stop at Surrey Hill, Arch Rock, and other highlights. You can book in advance or grab a same-day tour from downtown.
Insider Tip: If you’re staying on the island, you can also call a horse-drawn taxi to get around—just be prepared for a bit of a wait in peak hours.
Pretend You’re Fancy at the Grand Hotel
No Mackinac Island itinerary is complete without a visit to the Grand Hotel. Known for its stately white facade and the longest porch in the world, this National Historic Landmark is pure old-school glamor.
There’s a $12 admission fee for non-guests ($6 for children ages 6-12, free for children udner 5), but if you’re curious to explore the gardens, take photos on the porch, or just channel your inner Jane Seymour à la Somewhere in Time, it’s absolutely worth it. We laughed our way through the experience, feeling completely out of place—but also totally charmed.
Want to splurge? You can enjoy a cocktail at the Cupola Bar upstairs or afternoon tea in the parlor.
Dinner with a Harbor View
As your day winds down, treat yourself to a laid-back dinner overlooking the water. Some great options include:
- Mary’s Bistro Draught House – Craft beer, cozy vibes, great lakefront patio
- The Pink Pony – A Mackinac classic with live music and lively energy
- Seabiscuit Café – Intimate, quirky, and consistently delicious
We grabbed a table on a terrace, ordered cheese pizza, and watched the sailboats drift by. It was the perfect ending to our two-day island escape.
One Last Stop: Fudge
Before you catch your ferry back, stop into JoAnn’s Fudge or Murdick’s Fudge to grab a box (or five) of the famous sweet treat. It makes a great souvenir… if it lasts long enough to get off the island.
Tips for Planning Your Mackinac Island Itinerary
Planning the perfect Mackinac Island itinerary doesn’t have to be complicated—but there are definitely a few things you’ll want to know before you hop on the ferry.
How Many Days Do You Need on Mackinac Island?
Two days is the sweet spot. It gives you just enough time to experience the highlights—like biking to Arch Rock, exploring Fort Mackinac, and pretending you’re fancy at the Grand Hotel—without feeling rushed. If you’re really short on time, a one-day trip can still be magical. But if you have the option to stretch your stay, you’ll appreciate the slower pace.
Getting Around the Island
Cars are banned on Mackinac Island, which is part of the charm. The main ways to get around are:
- Bikes – Easily rentable by the hour or day
- Walking – Totally doable, but be prepared for hills!
- Horse-drawn carriages – Yes, it’s touristy. Yes, it’s 100% worth it.
I recommend biking the perimeter of the island (M-185) at least once—it’s 8.2 miles of scenic bliss.
What to Pack for Mackinac Island
Even in summer, the weather can be unpredictable. Here’s what I recommend bringing:
- Layers – Think light jacket or fleece
- Comfortable shoes – You’ll be walking and biking a lot
- A daypack – For ferry rides, snacks, and your fudge stash
- Refillable water bottle – Many places on the island have fountains
If you’re visiting in June, pack something purple for the Lilac Festival!
When’s the Best Time to Visit?
Late spring through early fall is peak Mackinac Island season. Here’s a quick breakdown:
- May–June: Lilacs bloom, and the crowds are just starting to build
- July–August: Peak season—best weather and longest days
- September: Quieter, but still beautiful
- Winter: Magical in its own way, but most businesses are closed
FAQs About Visiting Mackinac Island
Is 2 days enough time on Mackinac Island?
Yes! Two days is the perfect amount of time to see the island’s highlights without feeling rushed. You’ll be able to bike the perimeter, explore Fort Mackinac, visit the Grand Hotel, and still have time to relax with some fudge or take a carriage ride.
How do you get around on Mackinac Island?
The island is completely car-free, so you’ll get around by bike, on foot, or by horse-drawn carriage. Bike rentals are easy and affordable, and carriage taxis or tours offer a relaxing alternative.
When is the best time to visit Mackinac Island?
Late spring through early fall is prime time, with June being especially popular for the Lilac Festival. July and August are busiest, but also offer the warmest weather. For fewer crowds, try September.
Where should I stay for this itinerary?
If you’re traveling on a budget, staying in St. Ignace or Mackinaw City and taking the ferry over is a great option. If you want the full experience, splurging on a night at Mission Point Resort or another island hotel is unforgettable.
Do you need tickets for Mackinac Island?
No tickets are required to visit the island itself, but you’ll need to purchase ferry tickets and admission for attractions like Fort Mackinac or the Grand Hotel grounds.
Final Thoughts on This Mackinac Island Itinerary
Visiting Mackinac Island felt like stepping into a storybook—where horses roam instead of cars, fudge is basically a food group, and time seems to slow down just enough to savor every moment. This Mackinac Island itinerary is a reflection of my own two-day adventure, packed with first-hand tips and honest reflections to help you plan your trip with confidence.
Whether you’re a fellow budget traveler, a lover of lake views, or just someone curious about this charming corner of Michigan, I hope this guide helps you fall in love with Mackinac Island just like I did.
Still have questions about planning your trip? Drop them in the comments—I’m happy to help!
One Comment