11 Incredible Captiva Island Restaurants You’ll Want to Dine At

When it comes to Captiva Island restaurants, the vibe is just as dreamy as the island itself — laid-back, a little quirky, and full of flavor. Whether you’re craving fresh seafood with a sunset view, casual bites with live music daily, or a slice of cake from an iconic house-turned-gallery, there’s no shortage of memorable meals to be had here.

As someone who’s been visiting Captiva for as long as I can remember, I’ve tasted my way around the island more times than I can count. From family dinners after a beach day to sunset cocktails with friends, I’ve personally experienced the charm, character, and seriously good food these local spots have to offer.

It’s not just about what’s on the menu — it’s about the feeling you get when you dine steps from the sand, or when your cake arrives towering and frosted like a dream.

Over the years, I’ve kept coming back to my tried-and-true favorites (The Bubble Room, I’m looking at you), while also discovering newer gems that deserve a spot on your list. In this guide, I’m sharing my favorite restaurants on Captiva Island — many of which are open daily, serve up incredible food, and capture the spirit of this special little place.

Let’s dig in.

Planning your island getaway? Be sure to check out my full Captiva Island travel guide for everything you need to know!

Are There Restaurants on Captiva Island?

Absolutely — there are plenty of restaurants on Captiva Island, and they’re just as delightful and unique as the island itself. From colorful cantinas to cozy seafood houses with menus full of fresh local catches, this little barrier island knows how to bring the flavor.

Many Captiva Island restaurants are open daily, and several offer live music, beachside dining, and incredible sunset views. Even after several hurricanes in a row, the island’s dining scene has bounced back strong, with beloved spots reopening their doors and new favorites popping up to take their place.

1. The Bubble Room (Temporarily Closed)

I’ve been coming to Captiva Island for as long as I can remember, and no trip ever felt complete without a stop at The Bubble Room. It’s not just one of the most iconic Captiva Island restaurants — it’s an experience.

With floor-to-ceiling vintage toys, twinkling holiday lights no matter the season, and model trains zipping around the ceiling, walking through the doors feels like stepping into a time capsule dreamed up by a kid with a serious sweet tooth.

Opened in 1979, The Bubble Room is a beloved island institution, known just as much for its eccentric decor as for its towering cakes and comfort food classics. The menu leans retro (think cinnamon buns served with dinner), but the real star of the show? Dessert.

The Orange Crunch Cake is hands-down my favorite — moist, citrusy, and layered with just the right amount of sweet crunch.

Right now, The Bubble Room is temporarily closed due to damage from Hurricane Ian (and later damage by Hurricanes Helene and Milton), but the good news is it’s planning to reopen in May 2025. Until then, you can still get your cake fix next door at Boops — which brings me to…

2. Boops by the Bubble Room

When The Bubble Room closed temporarily after Hurricane Ian, I was heartbroken — until I discovered Boops. This sweet little café sits right next door and keeps the Bubble Room spirit alive with a colorful, nostalgic vibe and, most importantly, those legendary cakes.

Open daily from 8 a.m. to 8 p.m., Boops is the best place to grab a slice of that famous Orange Crunch Cake (yes, my favorite!) along with other classics like Red Velvet, Coconut, and Key Lime Pie. They also serve coffee, ice cream, pastries, and doughnuts, and have and Old Fashioned Soda Fountain!

The staff is always warm and welcoming, and there’s just enough seating if you want to enjoy your goodies right there. But honestly? I love grabbing my slice to go and eating it on the beach at sunset. It’s one of those simple Captiva pleasures that never gets old.

3. The Mucky Duck (Temporarily Closed)

If you’ve ever Googled “best Captiva Island restaurants with a view,” chances are The Mucky Duck popped right up — and for good reason. Tucked at the end of Andy Rosse Lane with nothing but sand and sea out front, this beloved beach pub has long been the go-to spot for fresh seafood, cold drinks, and some of the most spectacular sunsets on the island.

I’ve been coming here since I was a kid, and I still remember how fun it was to eat right on the beach — barefoot, sun-drenched, and completely in awe of how close we were to the water. We’d show up early to beat the dinner crowd, order baskets of fish and chips, and race down to the shoreline while waiting for our food. It was casual, carefree, and totally Captiva.

The menu has always been reliably good — think grouper sandwiches, peel-and-eat shrimp, and tropical cocktails — but the real star of the show was the view. Golden hour at The Mucky Duck is one of those things that sticks with you long after you’ve left the island.

Over the years, The Mucky Duck has weathered quite a few storms — literally. After suffering damage from Hurricane Ian in 2022, it became one of the first restaurants to reopen, just five months later. But more recently, Hurricane Milton caused extensive damage to the building, forcing another temporary closure.

There’s no official reopening date yet, but the team behind The Mucky Duck has said they’re determined to rebuild and return. Like so many other longtime Captiva visitors, I’m hoping to sit at one of those beachside tables again soon — sunset drink in hand, toes in the sand, and all.

4. Old Captiva House

Located at Tween Waters Island Resort, Old Captiva House blends Old Florida charm with elevated coastal cuisine — and it’s long been one of my favorite spots for a “fancy” night out on the island.

Growing up, we always did a special dinner on our first night in Captiva, and this was the go-to. I’d dress up (as much as you can when your suitcase is full of swimsuits), order a steak like I was a little adult, and feel very fancy while the grown-ups clinked glasses of wine. It’s still one of my most nostalgic Captiva traditions — and the food absolutely holds up.

The menu leans toward fresh Gulf seafood and seasonal ingredients, with dishes like lobster and crab crusted scallops and blackened snapper. But what often gets overlooked is how good their breakfasts are. I’m talking fluffy omelets, fresh pastries, and coffee with a view of the water. If you’re staying at Tween Waters, it’s basically a must — but even if you’re not, it’s worth going out of your way for.

The setting is classic and cozy, with touches of Old Captiva history (this spot dates back to the early 1900s!), white tablecloths, and warm hospitality. And while it feels upscale, it still totally fits the laid-back, beachy rhythm of island life.

Whether you’re celebrating something special or just want to treat yourself to a great meal, Old Captiva House is a standout.

5. The Green Flash

The Green Flash is hands-down one of the most scenic Captiva Island restaurants — perched right on the water with sweeping views of the Roosevelt Channel, Pine Island Sound, and the mangrove-draped beauty of Buck Key. It’s the kind of place where you could linger for hours, watching the birds or the sun dance across the water. And if you’re arriving by boat? Even better — just pull up to the dock and walk right in. (How Florida is that?)

If you do one thing here: sit on the back patio. It’s the most peaceful dining spot on the island, and the best place to soak in the waterfront views. Last time I was there, I snagged a patio table and ordered the seafood pasta special with lobster and shrimp — it was to die for. Rich, buttery, perfectly seasoned.

Inside, the restaurant has a warm, coastal feel with big windows and an easy elegance that’s just right for a nicer dinner out. The staff is welcoming, the drinks are strong, and the menu is packed with fresh seafood and rotating specials that change with the seasons.

Between the stunning views, the boat-up vibes, and the seriously good food, The Green Flash is one of those spots that makes Captiva feel extra magical.

6. Cantina Captiva

Cantina Captiva is one of those hidden-in-plain-sight Captiva Island restaurants that somehow slipped under my radar for years. Tucked just off Andy Rosse Lane in a funky little building covered floor to ceiling in dollar bills, it’s the kind of place you could walk past a dozen times and not realize what a gem it is inside.

I finally made it here for the first time in early 2020 — right before the world shut down — and I’ve been thinking about those tacos ever since. It was one of those spontaneous dinners where you walk in with sandy flip-flops and zero expectations… and leave full, happy, and wondering why you hadn’t been coming here all along.

The vibe is pure island quirk: colorful walls, handwritten messages on currency from visitors around the world, and a menu that’s part Tex-Mex, part coastal comfort food. Expect fresh guac, spicy shrimp burritos, and blackened fish tacos that hit all the right notes. The margaritas are strong (in the best way), and the staff always makes you feel like a regular — even on your first visit.

Whether you’re fueling up after a long beach day or just craving something a little spicier than your average seafood spot, Cantina Captiva is a laid-back, delicious surprise that absolutely deserves a spot on your island itinerary.

7. Keylime Bistro (Temporarily Closed)

Keylime Bistro has always been one of those feel-good Captiva Island restaurants — bright, colorful, and full of life. From lazy brunches in the courtyard to live music drifting through the air while you sip sangria and dig into a crab cake benedict, it had that breezy island vibe down to a science.

But the real reason I kept coming back? The key lime pie. Hands down, the best on the island. Tart, creamy, with just the right balance of sweetness and that graham cracker crust that dreams are made of. I’ve had a lot of key lime pie over the years (in Florida and beyond), and this one is the gold standard.

Sadly, Keylime Bistro has been closed since Hurricane Ian and, as of now, there’s no confirmed reopening date. Like many Captiva favorites, it was hit hard and is still working through the rebuilding process. I’m crossing all my fingers that it comes back soon — because the island just isn’t quite the same without it.

If and when they reopen, it’ll be the first place I head for pie.

8. RC Otter’s Island Eats

RC Otter’s is one of those Captiva Island restaurants that just feels like vacation. Colorful, casual, and always buzzing with live music and laughter, it’s the kind of place that makes everyone — especially kids — feel right at home.

With a sprawling patio and a constant stream of tunes from local musicians, the vibe here is lively and low-key all at once. It’s a great spot for families, with a kids’ menu that actually has options they’ll want to eat, and plenty of space for little ones to fidget without anyone batting an eye.

The menu is big and beachy — think grouper sandwiches, crab cake burgers, and shrimp every which way. I love how reliably good everything is, no matter what you order. And the portions? Let’s just say you won’t leave hungry.

Whether you’re coming off a long beach day or just want to catch some live music with your dinner, RC Otter’s is a feel-good favorite that keeps the island energy going strong.

9. Crow’s Nest Steakhouse

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Crow's Nest Steakhouse (@crowsnest.captiva)

The Crow’s Nest has come a long way from its pub days. What used to be a casual hangout with karaoke nights and bar food is now one of the most elevated dining experiences on Captiva Island — and I mean that literally. The restaurant has moved into a stunning new upstairs addition at Tween Waters Island Resort, and the views alone are worth the visit.

With huge windows overlooking the water and a fresh, coastal-modern design, it feels like a whole new era for the Crow’s Nest. It’s still warm and welcoming, but with a more polished vibe that makes it perfect for date nights, celebrations, or just treating yourself to a night of good food with a great view.

The menu has gotten an upgrade too — think prime steak selections, fresh Gulf seafood, and oyster appetizers that go well beyond typical island fare.

Whether you remember the old Crow’s Nest or are visiting for the first time, the new location and atmosphere make this one of the top Captiva Island restaurants to book for a sunset dinner.

10. Shipyard Restaurant

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by The Shipyard (@shipyardcaptiva)

The newest addition to the Captiva Island restaurant scene, The Shipyard has officially taken over the original Crow’s Nest space at Tween Waters — and it’s making a name for itself as the stylish new kid on the block.

Slightly more upscale than the bar that once called this space home, Shipyard still keeps things approachable, with a focus on fresh flavors and easygoing island charm. The vibe strikes a nice balance: polished enough for a special night out, but relaxed enough that you won’t feel out of place walking in straight from the beach.

The menu leans into coastal classics with a modern twist — think sesame blackened salmon, pork belly tacos, and drunken shrimp. The cocktails are creative and strong (just the way I like them), and the service feels attentive without being stuffy.

It’s always exciting to see new energy on the island, and Shipyard is a great addition. If you’ve been coming to Captiva for years, it’s fun to see how this familiar space has transformed — and if it’s your first time here, it’s an easy favorite to add to your list.

11. Captiva Crust

Another new kid on the block, Captiva Crust is quickly becoming one of my go-to Captiva Island restaurants — especially when I’m in the mood for something casual, flavorful, and a little different from the usual beach fare.

This artisan pizza spot brings a fresh, creative twist to the island’s dining scene, with hand-tossed pies, inventive toppings, and perfectly crispy crust. We’re talking everything from classic margherita to wild-card combos like Parmesan Ricotta cream sauce and bay scallops.

The best part? If you’re staying at or hanging around Tween Waters, you can order straight from the poolside bar. Yes — poolside pizza. It’s every bit as dreamy as it sounds.

Captiva Crust is a breath of fresh (and delicious) air, and a welcome addition to the island’s post-Ian comeback. It’s quick, convenient, and so much better than your average takeout slice — which makes it perfect whether you’re dining in, grabbing a box for sunset on the beach, or fueling up after a long day in the sun.

Looking for the perfect base while you eat your way through the island? Check out my guide to where to stay on Captiva Island for the best hotels, resorts, and vacation rentals.

Are Restaurants Open on Captiva Island?

Captiva Island’s dining scene has shown remarkable resilience in the face of recent challenges. After the devastation of Hurricane Ian in 2022, many restaurants worked tirelessly to reopen, bringing back the flavors and experiences that visitors cherish. However, the subsequent impact of Hurricanes Helene and Milton in 2024 led to temporary closures for some establishments, even those that had previously reopened.​

As of April 2025, numerous Captiva Island restaurants have reopened and are welcoming guests:​

• The Green Flash: This waterfront gem has not only reopened but is also expanding its offerings with a new Bayside Breakfast menu, featuring items like banana caramel french toast and bottomless mimosas.
• Cantina Captiva: After operating a food truck post-Ian, the restaurant is now open and thriving.
• Boops by The Bubble Room: While The Bubble Room itself is targeting a May 2025 reopening, Boops is serving up the iconic cake and other sweet favorites.
• Old Captiva House: Located at ‘Tween Waters Island Resort, this establishment reopened on October 5th, 2024, offering its signature coastal cuisine. ​
• Crow’s Nest Steakhouse: Having undergone a transformation, the Crow’s Nest has moved to an upstairs location, providing elevated dining experiences with stunning views. ​
• RC Otter’s Island Eats: Known for its family-friendly atmosphere and live music, RC Otter’s continues to serve guests in the heart of Captiva. ​

However, some beloved spots remain temporarily closed as they work through repairs and rebuilding:​

• The Mucky Duck: This iconic beachfront restaurant suffered significant damage from Hurricane Milton, leading to a temporary closure. The team is committed to restoring it to its former glory.
• The Bubble Room: After being closed since Hurricane Ian, The Bubble Room faced additional setbacks from Hurricane Milton. Efforts are underway to reopen with a target date of May 2025.
• Keylime Bistro: Closed since Hurricane Ian, Keylime Bistro faced further delays due to Hurricane Milton. While there’s no confirmed reopening date yet, efforts are ongoing to restore this beloved establishment.

For the most current information on restaurant openings and operations, it’s advisable to check individual restaurant websites or social media pages before planning your visit.

Tips for Dining on Captiva Island

Dining on Captiva is part of the experience — whether you’re catching a sunset over seafood or grabbing a slice of pizza to eat on the beach. But island dining comes with its own rhythm, so here are a few tips to help you make the most of it:

1. Make Reservations When You Can

Many Captiva Island restaurants are small, and while some operate on a first-come, first-served basis, others (especially the more upscale spots) do take reservations. If you’re traveling during peak season or planning a special dinner, it’s definitely worth booking ahead.

2. Go Early for Sunset Dining

Sunset is prime time on Captiva — and for good reason. Places like The Green Flash and The Mucky Duck (when open) fill up fast around golden hour. Arrive a little early, grab a drink, and soak up the view while you wait.

3. Check Hours Ahead of Time

Restaurant hours on the island can be… fluid. Many are open daily, but others close one or two days a week, especially in the off-season. Some are still operating with limited hours post-hurricane. Always check their website or give them a call before heading over.

4. Be Patient (Island Time Is Real)

Service on Captiva is friendly but relaxed. Expect to slow down a bit — this isn’t fast food, and that’s part of the charm. Bring good company, order a drink, and enjoy the slower pace.

5. Try Local Specialties

You can’t go wrong with fresh Gulf seafood here. Grouper sandwiches, shrimp tacos, crab cakes, and of course, key lime pie are must-tries. Each restaurant puts its own spin on the classics, so don’t be afraid to order them more than once.

6. Takeout Is a Sunset Hero

Don’t sleep on takeout! Grabbing a pizza from Captiva Crust or dessert from Boops and heading to the beach for sunset makes for a perfect low-key evening.

7. Support the Comeback

Many of the restaurants you’ll visit are still rebuilding after hurricanes Ian, Helene, and Milton. Showing up, tipping generously, and being kind to staff goes a long way toward helping this incredible little island bounce back.

Final Thoughts on Captiva Island Restaurants

Whether you’re craving a candlelit seafood dinner, a beachside burger with your toes in the sand, or the best slice of key lime pie you’ve ever had, Captiva Island restaurants deliver charm, flavor, and unforgettable views in every bite.

This little island has been part of my life for as long as I can remember, and every meal here feels like coming home — with a side of sunshine and sea breeze. From longtime icons like The Bubble Room to new favorites like Captiva Crust, there’s something here for every kind of traveler and every kind of appetite.

Planning your visit? Don’t miss my full guide to the island as well as posts on where to stay and things to do while you’re here.

And if you end up falling for this island like I have — well, don’t say I didn’t warn you.